Can Gillibrand Contend?

by Pitt Griffin on March 20, 2019 · 0 comments

in Election 2020, Politics

Kirsten Gillibrand is one of a large – and expanding – field of candidates for the Democratic presidential nomination. In an era of progressive resurgence, she is a retro-style conservative Democrat. In large part, because she established her political positions as a Representative in a conservative district in upstate New York.

Running for Senate she moved left to reflect the more liberal statewide views of the New York electorate. And, more importantly, to reflect the politics of the national Democratic base. She had to go from collecting votes in small towns and rural counties to one who had to appeal to voters in New York City and California.

Once in the Senate, her most notorious moment was her demand that Al Franken resign when pictures of him leering over a sleeping Leeann Tweeden while apparently grabbing her breasts on a USO tour. She announced he had to go and became a vocal advocate for his departure.

It didn’t go as well as she might have expected. Gillibrand calculated that the #MeToo movement demanded absolutism on politicians and other men who were accused of sexual assault. She miscalculated. Democrats saw her enthusiastic attacks on Franken as premature and ill-considered.

She upset progressives who thought she was not giving Franken the opportunity to defend himself. They thought he had the right to explain his behavior, and the photograph, before the Senate ethics committee. Especially as it would have given him the opportunity to stay in the Senate and remain a vocal champion of liberal politics

It rankled progressives that Franken had been forced out at a time when conservatives, including the President, could skate on ‘pussy grabbing’ and other tales of sexual aggression. Liberals wondered why Franken, whose ‘crime’ seemed lesser, should be Gillibrand’s focus. To some, her actions smacked of political expedience and cold calculation.

No matter how honestly she may have come about her position, to many she was seen as cynically catering to the women’s movement that is destined to have an enormous influence in deciding the 2020 Democratic presidential candidate. And in turn the presidential race itself.

Gillibrand has taken an aggressive stance against those who have questioned her on this. She said he said that if big donors were to shun her campaign, that would be ‘on them.’ It’s not a good look. It’s a political truism that if you are explaining you are losing.

Further, even if she is excused her Franken opportunism, she has the albatross of a sexual abuse claim in her own office. A staffer claimed that campaign employee Abbas Malik was harassing her. Gillibrand refused to fire him – and only did so after outside sources presented her with corroborating evidence she could have quickly discovered for herself.

Even if she dodges the hypocrisy charges, she faces formidable opposition from other women – including women of color.

In California, African-American Kamala Harris represents another big liberal coastal state – one with even more Electoral College clout.

Even among white, female candidates, Gillibrand is hardly the leading choice. Amy Klobuchar has the midwestern credibility that will prove crucial against Trump, who picked up so many Electoral College votes in the rust belt.

Elizabeth Warren is beloved by many liberals for her unabashed spanking of both banks and the regulators who oversee them.

Then there are the white men. Two stand out – Bernie Sanders with his rabid base and questionable relations with minorities, and Beto O’Rourke with his own army of devoted small donors and his centrist baggage.

Will Gillibrand be the Democratic nominee? She doesn’t lead in the polls (tied for 9th at 1%) or the odds (66 to 1 against), but it is early days yet. However, if she does want a shot at the brass ring she needs to fight on her high ground and not on the territory her enemies pick.


Theresa May’s Last Best Brexit Deal Rejected by Parliament

March 12, 2019

Having rejected a previous Brexit deal, the British Parliament voted today on a ‘tweeked’ version that British PM Theresa May had negotiated with the European Union. Parliament rejected the deal 391 — 242. There will be another vote in Parliament on whether the UK should exit the EU with no deal — the so-called “Hard Brexit”. If the MPs […]

Read the full article →

Fox and Friends Lie About an MS-13 Slaying in New York.

February 9, 2019

Last Sunday afternoon in Queens, NY a man was shot dead on a subway platform. A fight between three men and the victim had started on a Manhattan-bound train. As reported by NYPD Chief of Detectives Dermot Shea: “At some point, this confrontation turns physical, and as the train approached the 90th Street Station, the dispute spills onto […]

Read the full article →

John Dingell’s Final Published Words.

February 9, 2019

The following final published words from America’s longest-serving Congressman were published in the Washington Post. They are a testament to a great America. February 8 at 4:03 PMJohn D. Dingell, a Michigan Democrat who served in the U.S. House from 1955 to 2015, was the longest-serving member of Congress in American history. He dictated these reflections to his wife, Rep. […]

Read the full article →

Steve King’s Racism: A Timeline – With Comments.

January 18, 2019

Trip Gabriel of the New York Times put together a timeline of Rep. Steve King’s bigotry. I have reproduced it here with added comments. 2002 Mr. King, in the Iowa State Senate, files a bill requiring schools teach that the United States “is the unchallenged greatest nation in the world and that it has derived its strength from … […]

Read the full article →

A Little Girl Shows Conservatives Just Don’t Give a Damn.

December 16, 2018

A seven-year-old girl sets out with her father on a journey of 2,000 miles to seek asylum in the US. Conditions in her Guatemalan village were so dire that this dirty, exhausting trek across an inhospitable terrain seemed a better option than staying amidst fear and squalor. On arrival in the US, she is detained by border agents. Then, after eight hours […]

Read the full article →

What Would Republicans Have Called Melania if She Were Married to a Democratic President?

December 10, 2018

Jerry Falwell Jr. was interviewed Saturday night by Fox News’  Jesse Watters on his eponymous show, ‘ Watters’ World’. Being December, it didn’t take long for Watters to turn to the ‘War on Christmas’. That unique conflict where there are constant reports from the front, but no one is fighting. The conversation turned to Melania Trump’s White House Christmas […]

Read the full article →

From Argentina to Twitter, Trump Shows Evidence of Mental Decline.

December 10, 2018

Trump did not have a good weekend at the G-20 in Buenos Aires. He appeared befuddled when he wandered off the stage after shaking hands with President Macri of Argentina instead of staying for the ‘family photo’. And a mic caught him telling the aide who chased him down “Get me out of here”. Vladimir Putin and Mohammed bin […]

Read the full article →

Tariffs Are a Regressive Tax that Penalizes the Poor.

November 29, 2018

But who’s paying the $3 tariff? Whoever is buying widgets — in this case, the American consumer. Increasing the price of widgets by $3 is the equivalent of adding a 20% sales tax. However, that revenue would only come from Chinese widget sales. The Treasury would get no direct benefit from increased American widget sales.

Read the full article →